Client Revenue$96,120,614

Empirics or Theory First? A Case for an Empirics-First Approach That Develops Marketing-Relevant Insights from Real-World Problems

Updated November 10, 2022

Recent Posts

Get a Free Digital Marketing Quote!
Want to talk now?
Give us a call at
(702) 904-4262

Powered by OnSago

Content Key

Share this Post :

Over 50 years ago, academic research across several business disciplines was criticized for falling short of scientific standards. This led to a paradigm shift away from description and toward theory—a shift that was entirely appropriate and broadly successful. Now we ask: Has the pendulum moved too far? Is scientific legitimacy viewed so narrowly that it suppresses real-world relevance and limits the novelty of ideas that might be captured from starting with real-world observations?

It is time to entertain another paradigm shift, one where empirical evidence is revered more than theory. In a new Journal of Marketing study, we make a case for an empirics-first (EF) approach for research in marketing as opposed to the dominant theory-first (TF) approach. EF refers to research that:

  • is grounded in (and originates from) a real-world marketing phenomenon, problem, or observation,
  • involves obtaining and analyzing data, and
  • produces valid marketing-relevant insights without necessarily developing or testing theory.

In most published academic marketing research, a theory is borrowed, refined, or developed and then tested empirically. As a result, many papers published in leading marketing journals (especially in consumer research and strategy) follow a typical template: introduction → prior literature → overarching theoretical framework → hypotheses → empirical test → discussion.

We advocate for EF research that starts with a real-world marketing phenomenon, problem, or observation; exploits data; and develops valid marketing-relevant insights—with or without making an overture to theory. We note that several developments contribute to the timeliness (and timelessness) of the EF approach. One key driver is the quest for research relevance. EF research is often sparked by “data” from the real world, which means research can start down a fresh path, asking new questions unburdened by the demands of existing theory. In other words, the natural arc of the EF approach more easily bends back to real-world implications. Other developments contributing to the need for EF research include the availability of new data and analytical methods, the need for marketing to address critical real-world issues such as vaccine acceptance, climate change, and disinformation, and the confidence crises plaguing the social sciences around replicability and data manipulation.

Why Has EF Research Failed to Gain Traction?

Our research shows that strategy and experimental consumer research are most likely to abide by a TF approach. One possible reason is that TF research is well-represented in PhD education and uses a series of well-defined steps while EF research, which tends to be open-ended and unstructured, appears to lack rigor.

We explain that EF research consists of three stages. In the first stage – called “Identify Opportunity” – a meaningful, real-world issue with broad appeal to marketing stakeholders is selected. In the second stage – “Explore Terrain” – researchers use initial empirical insights to broaden and deepen the research scope. Finally, the third stage – “Advance Understanding” – aims to provide empirical regularities, conceptual and theoretical insights, and stakeholder advice.

The success of EF research rests both on proper execution and effective communication. EF scholars should be mindful of the expectations of the journal review team, many of whom may be steeped in the TF tradition. It should be made clear why the EF approach is appropriate for the particular research problem. Also, EF scholars are advised to justify the variables they study, explain their exact steps, report what worked and what did not, test robustness, and report the results fully.

Challenge of Reporting EF Research

To effectively report the nonlinear process that makes up EF research, we recommend paying special attention to communicating the paper’s structure and narrative. Suggested tools include a flowchart to orient the reader at the start; structuring the paper based on the research questions; using section, table, and figure headings that guide the reader; and providing explanatory bridges between the steps in the process.

We believe journal reviewers and editors should be open-minded and informed when evaluating EF research. Rather than demanding an overarching theoretical framework, a single theoretical lens, or perfectly clean results, they should be realistic about which robustness checks are feasible. Even if a robustness check does not confirm all findings, reviewers should view it as a learning opportunity. Reviewers also should not demand traditional theoretical implications or expect EF research to be reported as TF research as this can lead to HARKing (hypothesizing after results are known).

The EF path, when ambitiously and rigorously pursued, offers a way to address demands for relevance, novelty, replicability, and generalizability. The shift requires changes in the mindsets of authors, a more even balance between TF research and EF research in PhD education, and a journal review process that accepts the inherent tradeoffs in pursuing EF research. Our ultimate objective is to pave the way for EF to enter the mainstream of academic marketing research.

Read the full article

From: Peter N. Golder, Marnik G. Dekimpe, Jake T. An, Harald J. van Heerde, Darren S. U. Kim, and Joseph W. Alba, “Learning from Data: An Empirics-First Approach to Relevant Knowledge Generation,” Journal of Marketing.

Go to the Journal of Marketing

The post Empirics or Theory First? A Case for an Empirics-First Approach That Develops Marketing-Relevant Insights from Real-World Problems appeared first on American Marketing Association.

Join our email list for marketing strategies, website tips and ux improvements, and business insights.

About the Author

Justin is a local marketing expert with over 15 years of experience creating brand recognition around digital strategies.

Leave a Reply

Get a Free Digital Marketing Quote!
Want to talk now?
Give us a call at (702) 904-4262

Powered by OnSago

More Great Posts

McKen’s Mexican Grill Digital Menus

We did all the digital menus for McKen’s Mexican Grill in Downtown Las Vegas. [su_carousel source=”media: 213,212,211″ link=”lightbox” width=”1000px” height=”250px” responsive=”no” title=”no” autoplay=”4700″ speed=”500″] ADs

Read More »
Advertise with us
Join our advertising network to grow your business. Give us a call at (702) 904-4262
Rank #1 on Google with 702 Pros | Sidebar Advertisement | 702 Pros SEO
Sponsored
34.99 WordPress Updates | WordPress Support by 702 Pros
Sponsored
Best Top #1 Empirics or Theory First? A Case for an Empirics-First Approach That Develops Marketing-Relevant Insights from Real-World Problems | Empirics or Theory First? A Case for an Empirics-First Approach That Develops Marketing-Relevant Insights from Real-World Problems Agency | Justin Young, US Air Force Veteran and CEO of 702 Pros
Justin Young Signature - 702 Pros

Justin YoungCEO of 702 Pros

I'm Justin Young
Air Force Veteran, Founder and CEO of 702 Pros.

I lead our team to grow our client’s businesses with smart and innovative web design and digital sales systems. I treat every business like it were my own, giving each the attention it deserves. In short, our experts will focus on delivering the best results producing the greatest ROI for your business.

Let’s talk about your business!

VOSB CVE AWARD

Our Empirics or Theory First? A Case for an Empirics-First Approach That Develops Marketing-Relevant Insights from Real-World Problems Agency will work hard to make sure your business succeeds online

Our Empirics or Theory First? A Case for an Empirics-First Approach That Develops Marketing-Relevant Insights from Real-World Problems experts are waiting to build your business credibility like never before. Let our team help grow your brand with digital marketing & WordPress management solutions, built around producing the highest return on your business investment.

2021Winner
Best Web Design Agency in
2021Winner
Best Digital Marketing Agency in
2021Winner
Best SEO Agency in

Deals on Web Design Pricing in

Hurry our web design deals in will only last for a limited time only. Our team of web designers have the experience and knowledge to get your business off to the best start possible or improve your business presence with SEO , digital marketing , web support and website hosting

20% off Web Design Deal Ends Soon!

Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds

Grow with the Pros

Let us know about you to get started.

A problem was detected in the following Form. Submitting it could result in errors. Please contact the site administrator.

Want to talk now? Give us a call at (702) 904-4262

Powered by OnSago

Ready to speak with a marketing expert?

Call our team @
+1(702)904-4262

Our Pros have your back with award-winning design and marketing,Including proven systems focused on producing the best return on your investment.

702 Pros is veteran-led design by Justin Young—Air Force Veteran and Digital Marketing Authority.

2021Winner
Best Web Design Agency in the United States
702 Pros Landscape Logo Vector - with url and grow with digital catchphrase
Google Partners
Meta Business Partners
Inc 5000

FAQs

There are definitely benefits associate with hiring a local website hosting provider over a large hosting provider like Godaddy. One, you have a clear company
There are definitely benefits associate with hiring a local website hosting provider over a large hosting provider like Godaddy. One, you have a clear company
Why – in a world of website builder tools would someone possibly hire a professional web designer to do a website for them? Short
Hiring a web designer can be a tough decision for any business to make. It can be even more of a challenge working with
702 Pros was created in 2015 and registered as a business in Las Vegas, NV in early 2016.
Our web design services include service business web design, e-commerce web design, artist portfolio web design, photography portfolio web design, restaurant website design, entertainment

Meet Our Team

I’m Justin Young, the Founder and CEO of 702 Pros. Let’s build something amazing, challenge our minds with creative and insightful development.

Justin Y.

Founder and CEO

Hi All! I oversee complete operations at 702 Pros. I’m passionate and dedicated to helping continue innovation and growth of local businesses.

Ashley M.

Chief Operations Officer

Kyla E.

Client Relations

My name is Johann Olivares, I am a Web Developer for 702 Pros and I build and design awesome Web Applications with my web dev team and aim to get better each day. Sidenote – I am a huge Dragon Ball Fan.

Johann O.

Web Developer
Kyla Sloan | Kyla Estes | Client Management | Reception | Sales
Advertising with Us
Kyla SloanAdvertising Specialist
Our team has the digital and traditional marketing skills to get you in front of customers looking for your product or service.
Want to talk now? Give us a call at (702) 904-4262

Powered by OnSago

Add Your Business To the 702 Pros' Directory
Please add some general information about your business.
A problem was detected in the following Form. Submitting it could result in errors. Please contact the site administrator.
Want to talk now? Give us a call at (702) 904-4262

Powered by OnSago

2022 Sale

Get 20% off!

All Web Design Packages
A problem was detected in the following Form. Submitting it could result in errors. Please contact the site administrator.
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
Want to talk now? Give us a call at (702) 904-4262

Powered by OnSago

Justin Young - Founder and CEO of 702 Pros | Web Design Las Vegas | Las Vegas Marketing Agency | best web design company in las vegas | Digital Marketing Agency | Web Design Agency | Top Web Design Agency
Schedule a Free Digital Strategy CallOur team is ready to grow your business!